Sunday, August 10, 2008

Notes from VirginFest

This year's full-blown rock festival post complete with pictures, band-by-band coverage, etc. won't come until next month, when Maureen and I fly to Texas for Austin City Limits. But here's an abbreviated report from the first day of VirginFest:

As the world becomes ever more inter-connected, there's a certain fear that globalization will ultimately lead to a thin grey soup of culture, into which all the national distinctions we treasure dissolve. You feel it when you walk down a graceful Parisian boulevard in spring and hear dread words like "Ou est le KFC?" Or when you get the feeling that we're headed toward a future where there's an Irish pub on every corner but no actual authentic Irish people left, in Ireland or elsewhere. Call it the tragedy of the cultural commons. 

On the other hand, you've got bands like Gogol Bordello, which essentially answers that age-old question, pondered by philosophers throughout the years: What would happen if Frank Zappa had been born into family of gypsies in the Ukraine in 1972, fled the Chernobyl meltdown, and ended up on the lower east side of Manhattan, where he founded an Eastern European folk/punk band that includes a Russian fiddler, Russian accordion player, Israeli guitar player, Ethiopian bassist, two backup singers of Thai and Chinese heritage dressed in roller derby outfits, and (naturally) an Ecuadorian percussionist / MC? 

Similarly, lets say your whole act consists of a man and woman, both Mexican, sitting on a pair of chairs, each playing an acoustic guitar, with no vocals and an uncategorizable sound that begins with Latin influences and then wanders through rock structures, salsa, flamenco, and the occasional Led Zeppelin cover. How awesome do you have to be to end up on the main stage at VirginFest? Answer: ten kinds of awesome, or Rodrigo Y Gabriela. 

In other words, as with most things, there are plusses and minuses of bringing the world's cultures together. On the whole, I say thumbs up. 

Friday, August 08, 2008

The Data Void

One of the interesting things about working on both K-12 and higher education policy is observing the differences between them. In K-12, there's a long-running and very active research and policy conversation about class size. Books have been written, studies conducted, debates organized, policies implemented, all focused on the relationship between student / teacher ratios and learning. People argue about whether there's a specific threshold class size associated with learning gains (15:1? 18:1?), whether there are differential effects for different student groups, whether marginal dollars are better spent hiring more teachers or better teachers.

All of this occurs despite the fact the class sizes in K-12 don't actually vary all that much. The vast majority are probably somewhere between 15 and 35 students. In higher education, by contrast, class sizes in similar courses can range from less than 10 to 500 or more. In theory, that should permit for even more robust inquiry into the impact of college class size on teaching and learning, particularly since student / faculty ratios are a commonly-accepted and often-used measure of institutional quality.

Yet virtually no such research exists. And this is true for lots of other basic elements of the higher education teaching enterprise. This is the subject of my new column at InsiderHigherEd. Read it here.

Beer Pong Ain't Wimbledon

This paragraph from Inside Higher Ed's article today about efforts to rid college campuses of drinking games makes me wonder if the author has a little experience with the topic...

Like many drinking games, beer pong’s beauty lies in its simplicity. Played on a ping pong table, the object is to toss a table tennis ball across a net and land it in a beer-filled cup on the other side. While the game has different rules in different circles, a successful shot often means your opponent has to chug a beer.

Not surprisingly, beer pong ain’t exactly Wimbledon.

Thursday, August 07, 2008

Woeful

Sol Stern of the Manhattan Institute says:

There are some districts in [New York] state that recorded proficiency rates of close to 100% on this year's math tests. This Lake Wobegon effect is an embarrassment...

Look, if you're going to start throwing around tired cliches instead of offering actual analysis, at least get the cliches right. As everyone (except, apparently, Sol Stern) knows, the Lake Wobegon effect refers to the mathematically specious idea that, to quote Garrison Keillor, "all of the children are above average." Proficient is not average. Proficient means you've acquired a certain defined set of knowledge and skills. While the percent of students who can reasonably be expected to meet any given definition of proficiency is debatable, there's no inherent generalized reason that it can't be "close to 100%." There are lots of of important things that close to 100% of people can do.

Sharpton and Carey, together at last

I'll be on the Reverand Al Sharpton show talking about class-based school integration policies, starting in about five minutes. I think you can listen here.

Update: The muzak you hear while on hold waiting for the Reverand? Tremendously funky.

Update 2: The first segment seems to have gone well. Good questions. Keeping it real!

Update 3: On to the callers! Jack from Baltimore says the public school system gets a lot of money but wastes it; we need higher standards, AP course, hold the administrators to account. Can't argue with that.

Update 4: Very frank conversations about parental involvement.

Update 5: The last caller veers toward some kind of FCAT conspiracy theory in Florida -- the easy tests go to some communities, the hard ones to others...but then the segment ends.

Summary: Good topic, interesting mix of callers, the Reverand Al was engaged and on point. Notice to producers and bookers: contact Education Sector for smart, well-informed guests!

What We Do Cannot Be Measured

Two main camps square off in education over and over again. One side, typified by the Broader, Bolder coalition in K-12, emphasizes student demographics. They point out, justifiably, that students enter school with widely divergent skills and expectations. As such, schools can only do so much to rectify the situation. The other, reformist side, says demographics be damned, every child deserves a quality education. Children and schools should all be held to high standards, and we can account for differences on the back end.

The first camp is far less willing to measure results in any systematic way. It makes some sense too. If you believe demography is destiny, no mathematical formula, no matter how complex or inclusive, can address all the factors that go into schooling.

Let's leave the math and the standardized achievement measures alone for a bit. Surely there are other ways to measure a school's, or even an individual teacher's, value? The first crowd says no. Insidehighered published a piece today questioning learning assessments in colleges. The author, Bernard Fyrshman, argues that, because colleges educate many different types of students in many fields, we cannot encapsulate a school's contribution to learning in a number:
Do you want to know whether the school will help a student learn to think, to examine, or to innovate? And of course every one of those talents may differ depending on the discipline. Do you care about what’s happening in the fine arts department or in engineering? And even in engineering, is it civil engineering or software development? Different talents, different intellectual demands, different skills.

But wait, we didn’t ask you yet about the student you’re interested in helping. Is he bright and driven, or laid back and not particularly ambitious? Was his high school a place that turned him on to learning or to text messaging? Does he need remedial coursework or is his transcript full of AP credits? Does your daughter stand out or is she happy sitting at the back of a large lecture hall? Will she grow under pressure or shrivel up and leave? Does your child want competition or collaboration?
The problem with Fryshman's argument, and the entire first camp's in general, is that we really have no good alternatives to assess student learning. In the higher ed world, colleges and universities have successfully kept new data sources from the public (see the recently passed Higher Education Act). For colleges, the only data we really have are graduation rates, and those mask wide differences. Some schools have small or nonexistent gaps between black and white graduation rates. Some, like my alma mater, a large public Big Ten school, have wide discrepancies.

But what about other sources of information? As Fryshman says, engineering students are different than ones studying fine arts. That's a given, but incomplete. How involved are they with campus life? How many papers or projects are they asked to complete? And are they able to find jobs after graduation? Are those jobs in their field of degree? If they graduated from a public school, do they stay in-state after graduation? Do they earn salaries worthy of their credentials? Are their employers satisfied with their skills? Do they go on to pursue, and to succeed, in more education? Are they involved in civic life through voting or volunteering? Most importantly, how do the answers to these questions stack up with the school's peers?

There's more than one way to take a measurement, but instead of pursuing other avenues vigorously, schools are mostly reluctant to release data proving their merit. We're left arguing, as Fryshman does, about standardized tests. But policymakers no longer accept accountability by assurance; they want to see results.

The GI Bill Equation

Jon Oberg (of whistle-blower fame) has a guest post over at Higher Ed Watch on the new GI Bill. While he praises the recent expansion of benefits, he also points out that it will take the cooperation of college financial aid offices in order for veterans to see the full benefits of the bill. As we've shown, colleges have been increasing the institutional aid they give to higher income students over the years, which means fewer dollars for low-income students - and possibly for veterans. Colleges can lessen the impact of federal grant aid by simply using it as an excuse to take away institutional aid the student would have otherwise received. Or colleges can join the federal government in increasing access to four-year institutions by supplementing the federal aid money to ensure veterans graduate with as little debt as possible.

This Chronicle of Higher Education ($) article from last month takes an interesting look at the impact of the GI Bill and the colleges--private, for-profit--that are reaping the biggest benefits from its expansion.

The Supposedly Unfriendly Skies

USAir charged me a dollar for a cup of coffee yesterday morning. I know this is supposed to make me angry, what with the evil airline industry coming up with ever-more-nefarious schemes to suck money from my wallet even as the flying experience deteriorates to levels formerly unknown outside of various former Soviet republics. But I just can't get worked up about it. Most of the whinging is unjustified, I think.

I fly fairly often, probably twice a month on average, short flights and long, national and international, for business and pleasure. It's usually fine. Yes, there's the occasional Kafkaesque nightmare of delays, brought in part by overscheduling. But there are ways to minimize the risk of this (i.e. never, ever connect through O'Hare in the summer, particularly in the afternoon). The seats are a little cramped, but I'm 6'2" and have broad shoulders, so I imagine it's not as bad for most people. Plus, technology is making some things better -- nifty noice-cancelling headphones, for example, and they're going to have wi-fi any day now. The food and coffee they sell in the airport to bring on board is a lot better. Plus, people can't smoke anymore.

So I'd say the experience is a wash, then add on the fact that airline travel is (A) much cheaper than it used to be, and (B) phenomenally safe. Those two things are all most people really care about, and the market has reacted accordingly. It's not like USAir is Exxon/Mobil and they're reaping windfall profits by charging for soft drinks; most of the airlines either went bankrupt recently or are getting there soon. It's properlyiregulated capitalism, and in the long run things tend to work out.

For example, on my return flight, the flight attendant came down the aisle with the beverage cart. "Soft drinks? Coffee? Anyone?" There were probably 60 people on the plane and I don't think a single person bought a drink. So there you have it: for decades airlines have been spending a not-inconsiderable amount of money providing free drinks and snacks that people actually don't want very much, but overconsumed because that's what people do when things are free. And of course they weren't free; the cost just got rolled into the ticket. Now tickets will be a little less expensive, people will only drink cheap coffee or soda if they really want to, and the world will be a slightly more efficient and productive place. That's progress.

Monday, August 04, 2008

Obama on Affirmative Action

As the New York Times noted yesterday, Barack Obama sensibly believes that his daughters shouldn't benefit from affirmative action when they apply to college, particularly if it comes at the expense of less-privileged white applicants. Applying a much stronger economic lens to college admissions is a good idea and I'm glad Obama agrees. Because college admissions is zero-sum, that might mean trading some racial diversity for income diversity. But if that means the children of two wealthy, powerful, and socially-prominent Ivy League-educated lawyers don't get into Princeton, it's a trade off worth making.

Some affirmative action proponents, however, are worried that introducing this kind of nuance to the debate will hurt the larger cause (hat-tip: Russo):

The Supreme Court has...said that universities could consider race as they worked to diversify their campuses. Proponents of such programs point out that blacks continue to face discrimination regardless of class or income. Some fear that Mr. Obama’s focus on the socioeconomic status of his daughters — as opposed to the diversity of experience and perspective they might bring to predominantly white campuses — may help conservatives in their battle to eliminate race from university admissions and government hiring.

This just shows the how screwed-up the affirmative action debate has become. I'm in favor of racial preferences in college admissions as long as the goal is to help minority students who come from substandard K-12 schools and have to live with legacy of historical racism along with discrimination that still exists today. But somehow affirmative action has gotten turned around so that the primary justification is now that it's good for white people. This is partially the legacy of Sandra Day O'Connor's somewhat tortured logic in the Michigan case, and partially because diversity has been diluted into a kind of all-purpose social good that's handy for any rhetorical occasion. It's also a way to be pro-affirmative action without being intellectually honest about the hard tradeoffs that position entails, and leads to absurd conclusions like the idea that some other Senator's daughter would learn more from hanging out with Senator Obama's daughters at Princeton than she would from a white first-generation college student from a low-income family.

Elsewhere in the article there's also this:

Charles J. Ogletree Jr., a professor at Harvard Law School and an adviser on black issues to Mr. Obama...and civil rights lawyers like Mr. Payton say Mr. Obama’s daughters should not be barred from affirmative action programs because they may well encounter racial discrimination, unlike their white peers. Studies suggest that employers often favor white job seekers over black applicants, even when their educational backgrounds and work experiences are nearly identical. Mr. Obama’s “daughters are not going to be judged in a colorblind way throughout their lives,” Mr. Ogletree said.

I'm pretty sure that the single biggest thing affecting the way people judge Barack Obama's children throughout their lives will be the fact that their dad was a world-famous Senator and possibly the President of the United States of America, not their race, gender, or anything else. And while this is somewhat of an extreme example, many students at the relatively small number of elite colleges where affirmative action is an issue have social capital that dwarfs that of ordinary students.

Affirmative action is meant to help students who were, say, raised by a single parent who struggled to earn enough to put food on the table, students of promising intellect who bounced around from different schools in their younger years. Students, in other words, like Senator Obama himself (the article suggests that Obama "chose not to mention his race in his application to Harvard Law School to avoid benefiting from affirmative action," although this is unconfirmed.) But once it works, it shouldn't become an intergenerational inheritance, particularly when there are far more worthy lower-income students out there than elite institutions currently choose to serve.

Sunday, August 03, 2008

How to Know Your "Merit" Financial Aid Is Out of Whack

Last night my wife and I were sipping adult beverages at a swanky Georgetown pizza and beer joint. This is Georgetown, not exactly your local Pizza Hut. I overheard the couple next to us talking about Harvard's financial aid plan. He was describing how it works:
He: Students under $60,000 pay no tuition.
He (whispering): And they give need-based aid for families making up to $180,000.
She (incredulous): $180,000? That's a lot.
My sentiments exactly.

Friday, August 01, 2008

Charts You Can't Trust (continued)

When done well, graphs and charts tell a story or make a point quickly and coherently. Education Sector has a regular feature we call Charts You Can Trust, where we use a new data source to make a point about the state of education policy. You can read them all here. Despite Kevin's best intentions, we've never actually run one you can't trust. That critique is left for The Quick and the Ed.

Look at the chart below*. It measures the changes in the University of Georgia's undergraduate female enrollment (a pretty hot issue right now).
The chart makes it seem like some big changes were occurring down in Athens. But in reality, if you took the time to calculate the difference between the Fall 2002 and the Fall 2006 female enrollments, you'd find a change of 521 students, or a little less than 4%. To show this reality, the chart should have looked something like this:I suppose we could quibble about whether you should always make 0 the baseline for graphs, but I think we can all agree on the need for honest visual presentations.

*You can find this chart or make your own at the University System of Georgia website here. I made several; some were normal, but quite a few looked like the one above.

HEA, at Long Last

Congress passed a new version of the Higher Education Act yesterday, which President Bush is expected to sign. This is a real milestone -- it's been ten years since the last reauthorization, which is supposed to happen every five years. There's a lot in there to discuss, but in my mind the most disappointing thing is that even as InsideHigherEd calls it a "Huge, Exacting Accountability Bill," and institutions begin complaining about various onerous reporting requirements, the legislation is arguably a step backward on the kind of higher education accountability that matters most.

Basically it increases accountability (via public reporting and "shame lists") for a pretty meaningless measure (year-over-year percentage increase in tuition) while reducing the ability of the U.S. Department of Education to increase accountability for what really does matter--student learning--via the accreditation process. It also prohibits the department from modernizing its data reporting system, basically an anti-accountability measure passed under the guise of bogus arguments about student privacy. The irony is that, as I've written previously, holding down the cost of college--the one thing everyone in Congress seems to cares about--actually requires greater accountability for results, because one of the big things driving up costs is the current perception that price and quality are one and the same.

This is a short-term victory that will exact a long-term cost, not just to students and the public treasury, but to colleges and universities themselves. The vast majority of institutions would be better off in a world where perceptions of higher education quality are more closely tied to their core educational mission. But they're stuck playing a game they can't win, where perception of quality and the resulting rewards are all defined in terms of wealth, status, and exclusivity. Exclusivity is a zero-sum game, while wealth and status involve massive early-entrant, rich-get-richer advantages--basically if you're an old, famous, and rich university today, the odds are exceedingly high that you'll remain so, and probably become more so.

Your typical community college, regional private college, or public university--i.e. where the large majority of Americans actually go to college--would benefit from very different status signifiers that gave them points for being good at what they were designed to be--places that teach students. But they can't change the rules--that's what the government is for. And now the government has caved into the interests of institutions at the top of the status pyramid, leaving all the rest, and their students, and the public at large, out in the cold.

Five years from now--let's hope it's not ten--when all the new measures have utterly failed to hold down rising costs, student debt is still growing at a rapid pace, and policymakers still have no idea whether or not colleges and universities are doing a good job, let's hope Congress makes different, better choices.

Update: See also New America's comprehensive run-down of the best and worst of HEA.

Thursday, July 31, 2008

Wholly Anecdotal Sign of the Education Apocalypse

In a taxi on the way to the Miami airport yesterday, talking to the driver, a part-time student at Florida International University, 25 years old, working on an accounting degree, family came to the U.S. from Dubai, born and raised in Miami. Seems perfectly nice, reasonably smart, etc. Asks me where I'm from: Washington, DC, I answer. The capital, right? he asks. How's George Bush? Then he remarks: My sister lives there, her boyfriend was transferred to Seattle. There are two Washingtons, I remind him. Right, right, he says--I always get that confused. So it's cold up there now, right, not all hot and humid like here? Because you're so close to Canada?

Carey / Pipp / Rivers

In my continuing effort to be Joan Rivers to Rick Hess' Johnny Carson -- or perhaps Wally Pipp to his Lou Gehrig -- I again did the Fordham Institute's Gadfly podcast today along with host Mike Petrilli (who, incidentally, does a good job of unpacking the tensions between achievement gaps as measured by relative- vs. criterion-referenced measures here).

Who Watches the Watchmen? Hopefully, Me

Lost in the generally well-deserved praise for The Dark Knight and the subsequent chatter over the million kabillion dollars it's raking in at the box office is the fact that it featured a trailer for Zach Snyder's Watchmen. Interestingly, it looks like the long-awaited/feared adaptation of Alan Moore and Dave Gibbon's seminal 80's graphic novel (which is generally--all though by no means universally--regarded as the greatest comic book ever made) may not suck. If that turns out to to be the case, I'm guessing this is why:


Many in Hollywood have tried to get Watchmen on the screen and failed, including directors Terry Gilliam (Brazil), Darren Aronofsky (The Fountain), and, most recently, Bourne Supremacy director Paul Greengrass. In 2005, Greengrass was deep into preproduction on a present-day, war-on-terror-themed adaptation by David Hayter (X-Men), when a regime change at Paramount Pictures led to its demise. Enter Warner Bros., which acquired the rights in late 2005. Snyder was working on 300 for the studio at the time, and he was alarmed when he heard about the deal. After some soul-searching, his fear of seeing a bad Watchmen movie trumped his fear of trying to make a great one. ''They were going to do it anyway,'' he says. ''And that made me nervous.'' Over many months, and many meetings, Snyder persuaded Warner Bros. to abandon the Greengrass/Hayter script and hew as faithfully as possible to the comic.

Debates over fidelity to source material in adaptation have been around about as long as the movies themselves. The filmmakers' position has always been: "the logic of what makes a good movie isn't necessarily the same as what makes a good (fill in source, usually a book). My first obligation is to the film and the viewer, not the author or the fan." And properly so, there are plenty of examples of adaptations that not only honored the original but transcended it. Often, the need for filmmakers to veer from the source stems from inherent differences in media: books are made of words, while movies are made of sounds and images. You can linger over words, which excel at revealing the inner lives of characters, while the sounds and images in movies force their pace upon you, and excel at evoking an emotional response in the viewer. Experiencing them is different, and so translation can be hard.

Comic books occupy a middle ground between books and movies: they're about words and images. This argues for a default filmmaking approach closer to faithful adaption, since presumably the unusually compelling or skillful use of sequential images is one of the big reasons the comic book is adaptation-worthy in the first place. The extent to which this is true, however, will vary by comic book. As we discussed previously, work by a primarily visual and purposefully cinematic creator like Frank Miller more or less demands panel-by-panel adaption, an approach Snyder used to great effect in 300. Alan Moore is a more interesting case. His particular genius is for understanding and manipulating the way readers experience words and pictures simultaneously, or in extremely close proximity. In most comic books, the words simply communicate what pictures can't: human dialogue. In Watchmen there's a constant and often subtle interplay between the words on the panel and the images behind, before, and after them, and that extends to both the foreground action and background settings. A lot of this isn't obvious on the surface; like most great books, Watchmen benefits from multiple readings. That's why Moore said "'There are things we did [in Watchmen] that could only work in a comic, and were indeed designed to show off the things that comics can do that other media can't.''

That's also why the greatness of Watchmen is kind of hard to explain; Maureen asked me about it while we were walking out of Dark Knight, and I was reduced to something along the lines of "Well, it's nominally a murder mystery but really kind of an exploration of the underlying tropes and themes of traditional super-hero comics seen through the lens of real-world cold war paranoia...ah, you really have to just read it."

And it's why there's never been a really good Alan Moore comic book adaptation to date. In League of Extraordinary Gentlemen they took the basic premise, threw out half the characters and all of the story, and made an phenomenally bad film. Their mistake was thinking that--as with Superman, Batman, and Spider-man--the premise was the thing. It's not; it's what Moore and Kevin O'Neil did with it, and what they did is close to untranslatable. From Hell, by contrast, was a pretty decent movie (scripted by Matt Yglesias' father, if I'm not mistaken), because the filmakers realized that the extremely long, dense, visually stylized (and tremendously good) comic book is wholly infilmable, while the premise (Jack the Ripper) is very strong. So they made a semi-adaptation that works pretty well on its own terms. V for Vendetta was more faithful, and thus was pretty good; there I think many of the shortcomings derive from the source material itself.

The value of Watchmen is clearly not the premise (see my lame explanation to Maureen above). Thus any huge divergence from the source, e.g. a "present-day, war-on-terror-themed adaptation" is doomed to fail. But unlike From Hell it may actually be filmable, and if so the key will be the work of artist Dave Gibbons. Like many of the best British comics artists (Preacher's Steve Dillon is another good example) Gibbons is first and foremost a great storyteller who avoids the temptations of stylistic flashiness and focuses on composition, drama, character, inter-panel transition, background detail, etc. And back in the 80s, Moore himself (who provides elaborate descriptions of every panel; the Absolute edition of Watchmen contains his script for the first page, which consists entirely of a single seven-panel fixed tracking shot, and yet the script is like 2,000 words long) was still writing comics using more traditional visual grammar.

All of which makes Snyder's decision to hew closely to the source look like a good one--those shots of Dr. Manhattan striding across the killing fields of Vietnam and his glass palace rising from the sands of Mars look pretty darn cool. Maybe, just maybe, Watchmen will be worth watching.

Boundary Changes

This situation in Fairfax County, VA has some relevance to recent discussions about socioeconomic desegregation plans (see also here and here).

In Fairfax, kids aren't being transported away from their neighborhood school for integration, but the school board did decide to change attendance boundaries to balance enrollments among schools, and took socioeconomic integration into account in its decision. Many of the parents whose children were assigned to South Lakes High School were not happy. South Lakes is under-enrolled by 700 students and has a newly remodeled facility, but it also has a higher percent of low-income students.

Parents filed a lawsuit to stop the school board, arguing, among other things, that the school board overstepped its bounds in trying to balance socioeconomics among the schools. After losing the lawsuit, parents have been requesting transfers to get their kids into their old assigned schools. Many parents are citing the lack of AP classes at South Lakes as a reason for their transfer requests.

As this situation makes clear, changing attendance boundaries is politically difficult, particularly when it increases socioeconomic integration. But this situation also illustrates why socioeconomic integration may be important - if these parents can raise $125,000 to sue the school board, they probably also have the clout to get more AP classes into South Lakes High School, and that's the kind of parental involvement that improves the quality of education for all students.

Tuesday, July 29, 2008

Economic Theory in Teacher Salaries: Why the ProComp Negotiations Matter

Imagine you have complete control over a new school district. You need to design a salary structure that fits what we know about education. Empirical evidence suggests that:
  1. Teachers have steep learning curves, making dramatic improvements in the first few years, but showing few gains, or possibly even slowing, as they near retirement.
  2. Teachers, as public employees, often have enormous retirement incentives to stay in their job near the end of their career to max out their defined benefit pension plan.
  3. After teachers earn tenure, they secure due process rights that make it difficult for them to be removed.
  4. The true value of teachers is difficult to measure, and while we've gotten much better at assessing merit, no one indicator, and certainly no proxy, has proven to be sufficient.
  5. Teacher quality, as measured by college GPA, college selectivity, and SAT score, has declined over time.
  6. Teachers with higher academic credentials, measured by college GPA, college selectivity, and SAT score, leave the profession earlier and in greater numbers.
  7. Teacher quality varies widely by school and subject, with younger and less-credentialed teachers concentrated in high-minority and -poverty schools.
Knowing these things, you must create a system for compensating teachers. There's a finite amount of money, so you can't just give all teachers what they deserve $100,000 and call it good. Instead, you have to use what you know to structure a salary system that is empirically based and fair.

You'd want to have a reasonable but not exorbitant starting salary, followed by a dramatic rise for teachers who have proven themselves on the job. Over time you would want to provide incentives for good teachers to stay, but you'd also want to make them demonstrate their merits through rewards for attaining greater educational achievement, working in high-needs schools or high-needs subjects, earning satisfactory evaluations, and for demonstrated value-added student growth.

In other words, you'd want a system like Denver's Professional Compensation System for Teachers (ProComp). Crafted after a four-year pilot program and a mixed teacher-administrator task force, ProComp, unlike most performance pay plans across the country, got funded through a citywide vote.

Union and district officials are currently negotiating the future of ProComp, and news reports ($) are showing the union taking particularly polarized positions. Union officials want a 3.5% across-the-board raise, but across-the-board raises have little empirical support. Worse, they're threatening a strike to get what they want, and to time the strike to correspond with the upcoming Democratic National Convention in the city.

District officials are asking for two main changes. They want to increase the starting salary $9,000, to $44,000, and they want to almost triple the amount, from $1,067 to $2,925, for teachers in high-needs schools and subjects. Those requests align well with the empirical lessons above. If evidence matters at all in education, it should help the district's objectives drive these negotiations.

The Libertarian Conspiracy to Destroy Public Education

Occasionally I'll use phrases like "conspiracy to destroy public education" in these pages, and you, faithful reader, may reasonably wonder whether I'm exaggerating for dramatic effect. I wish I were. But no, there really are people out there who simply want to dismantle the entire enterprise, despite evidence of public education's benefits so obvious that David Brooks wrote a whole column about them this morning. People like Neil McCluskey, associate director of the Cato Institute's "Center for Educational Freedom," who recently published a new policy brief explaining why public education is intrinsically un-American. Again, that's not bloggerly snark, it's the actual thesis: McCluskey believes that public education is a "fundamentally flawed--and un-American--institution" and a later subhead describes "Public Schooling's Un-American Ideals." Basically he argues that we had a perfectly swell free-market system of private schools in the first half of the 19th century which gave a great education to the small fraction of people who were legally allowed to vote, own property, etc., until that proto-communist bastard Horace Mann came along and ruined everything. Because, as we all know, American-ness is wholly a function of the political and social arrangements that prevailed in the years immediately following the founding of the Republic and any deviation from such clearly represents a grave national threat to be destroyed at all costs.

Monday, July 28, 2008

Republican Vice Presidential Picks and Education

While the edublogosphere has analyzed the candidates positions on education, speculated on various Secretary of Education possibilities, and commented on education spokespersons, it has yet to produce anything substantive on the policies of likely vice presidential picks. In order to keep the list manageable and relevant to TQATE, this discussion is limited only to widely speculated picks who also have an interest in education, our chosen issue. Let's start with the Republicans:

- Bobby Jindal, 37-year old governor of Louisiana, would bring spice to a McCain ticket. The son of Indian immigrants, Jindal has been called the "next Ronald Reagan" by Rush Limbaugh. Jindal has shown strong interest in education, serving from 1999-2001 as the president of the University of Louisiana System. During his tenure, he encouraged each school to develop one area of expertise and he got the eight state universities, as one, to recruit high schoolers to stay in-state. Governor since only January, Jindal has already touched some hot education issues, signing a modest voucher law and a law focusing on critical thinking skills, particularly towards evolution, cloning, and global warming.

Bottom line: Last week's joint McCain-Jindal events being disrupted by an oil spill and inclement weather could be the key omen. Plus, Jindal's youth weakens any McCain critiques on Barack Obama's inexperience. His education credentials are still a little thin to help or hurt John McCain this fall, but Jindal is a man to be watched.

- As a very good friend of John McCain, and governor of swing-state Minnesota, Tim Pawlenty has been and continues to be a favorite for the spot. Pawlenty has consistently chosen to make education one of his chief issues. He served 10 years as an attorney for the Minneapolis school district. As governor, Pawlenty chaired National Governors Association's education committee (before leading the whole organization), and in March he assumed the head of the Education Commission of the States. Most widely known is his passage of QComp, a statewide performance pay plan rewarding teachers for positive evaluations and student and school achievement scores. Pawlenty has also proposed summer teacher training academies that look similar to Teach for America's.

Bottom line: Pawlenty's a real contender for the spot, not least because of his strong friendship with McCain. His strong advocacy in education would supplement McCain's seeming disinterest in the topic.

- As governor of Massachusetts and as a candidate for President, Mitt Romney has taken education stands on many issues. An advocate for testing and accountability, Romney implemented Massachusetts' high school exit exam, and, during his campaign, was not shy about taking credit for his state's high NAEP scores. He successfully fought an attempt to stop the expansion of charter schools, but failed to pass performance pay or legislation granting the state a larger role in turning around struggling schools. His effort to increase students' time in schools became a small pilot program that has shown early, limited results. Romney successfully passed a large merit scholarship program, but failed spectacularly in a short-lived effort to restructure the governance of state colleges and universities. On the campaign trail he advocated for school choice and tax credits for home schooling and strongly opposed tuition support for children of illegal immigrants.

Bottom line: Romney is considered to have the best fundraising prowess of any on this list. That alone could be a big reason to call on him in a campaign against Obama's small donation machine. His ties to Michigan don't hurt either. On education, like his stances on other issues, Romney seems to be everywhere. Not necessarily in a good way.

- Another education-minded governor is Florida's Charlie Crist. He served as State Education Commissioner prior to winning the governorship in 2006. Crist has overseen major strife in his state's higher education governance structure. A 2007 report suggested a three-tier system with better defined mission focus. Third-tier schools would focus on undergraduate education, leaving the top tier to address graduate education and research. Its blog has only one post, but 2,752 comments. Starting in 2008, Crist-signed legislation that will allow state universities to charge different rates of tuition. Crist is also a supporter of the 65-cent solution to public education funding.

Bottom line: Crist is credited as almost single-handedly winning the Florida primary for McCain. It was a huge win, and geography alone could lead McCain to pick Crist. Crist's education platform looks similar to McCain's; here's hoping McCain does not take that as a good thing.

IKEA-Operated Schools?

The Associated Press writes about school choice in Sweden, where students and parents have, since 1992, been able to attend publicly financed, privately run schools of choice (they sound a lot like charter schools to me). And it's popular - 17 percent of high schoolers are now enrolled in one of these independent schools.

The article posits this as a radical change for Sweden, "that paragon of taxpayer-funded cradle-to-grave welfare". But 17 percent enrollment in privately run public schools would be pretty revolutionary for the U.S., too, and this isn't exactly a "cradle-to-grave" country.