Friday, July 25, 2008

Viva Las Vegas

I did a radio interview with KNPR today (the "N" actually stands for "Nevada" and was issued a long time ago, well before they knew what a great call sign that would turn out to be) focused on the Clark County (Las Vegas) school district's latest results under NCLB. Here's the beginning of the story in this morning's local newspaper:

The Clark County School District gave itself an "A" for its 2007-08 performance under federal standards, even though the number of schools needing improvement increased over the previous year and the number of schools showing improvement declined. In 2007-08, 186 schools made adequate yearly progress under the standards of the No Child Left Behind Act, 32 fewer than in 2006-07 when 218 schools showed adequate yearly progress. The number of schools on the state's watch list almost doubled, going from 35 in 2006-07 to 66 in 2007-08.

Deputy Superintendent of Instruction Lauren Kohut-Rost emphasized the rigor of the standards Thursday when the district released its annual report. Schools are judged by 37 separate targets. Falling short of just one target places a school on the watch list for failing to make adequate yearly progress. As a whole, the district met 94 percent of 12,987 benchmarks and expects to qualify for a second consecutive year as a district showing adequate yearly progress.

"That's an A grade we're giving ourselves," Kohut-Rost said. "We're extremely proud of the Clark County School District for making AYP for the second year in a row. That's almost unheard of for a very large urban and very diverse school system. So we're incredibly proud of that."


First, it's by no means unheard of for a large urban school district to make AYP two years in a row; most of them in fact are doing so, primarily because district-level AYP rules have been interpreted by states in extremely lenient ways.

Second, the oft-repeated idea that a school has to meet 37 out of 37 separate targets under NCLB (or some number in the same range, it varies a little by state) is for nearly all schools basically wrong. It's true that NCLB creates a two-dimensional matrix for each school crossing two performance measures (math and reading) plus two participation rates (95% of students have to be tested) with multiple student sub-group categories. So, for example, on one axis you'd have the four measures above, and on the other you'd have various student categories (white, black, Latino, asian, native american, low-income, special education, English language learner, all). 4 X 9 = 36, plus one additional measure (almost always attendance or graduation rates) equals 37.

But--and this is the crucial thing--very few schools have enough students to qualify in all 37 categories. For that to happen, a school would have to be large and enjoy some true United Colors of Benneton kind of diversity. In Nevada, subgroups aren't counted unless there are at least 25 students in the school, so to reach the full 37 you'd need at an absolute minimum of 125 (25 times each of the five racial/ethnic subgroups, with that population also containing significant numbers of poor, special education, and ELL students). Probably you'd need many more. Practically speaking, very, very few schools hit every box--and keep in mind, almost half of the boxes are simply test participation measures that have nothing to do with learning.

So a typical school is more likely to have between six and ten real marks to hit: reading and math performance for all students, one or two racial subgroups, and one or two among poor, special ed, and ELL. This is a lot less unreasonable-sounding than 37. It's why, six years into the law and counting, most schools haven't been labeled as failures. It also means that the "12,987 benchmarks" number is in all probability wildy overstated--I'll bet dollars to donuts that's the number of benchmarks against which Las Vegas schools could have been measured in an alternate universe where every single school in Clark County looks like the "It's A Small World" ride at Disneyland, not the number that was actually relevant after knocking out every subgroup under 25.

Third, the quotes from the school district officials illustrate an underappreciated point about the rationale behind NCLB. Holding schools accountable for test scores is usually characterized as a way to impose some uniformity to the education system, to make sure we bring all students up to the same high standards in a global economy, avoid the soft bigotry of low expectations, etc.-- all of which is true. But it's also a way to make judgment external to those being held accountable. That's what makes recent discussions about locally-designed assessments under a new version of NCLB so problematic. It's not so much what locals would be assessing as the fact that they'd be assessing themselves.

And when you give public officials in high-pressure, high profile jobs that kind of discretion, you tend to get responses along the lines of "That's an A grade we're giving ourselves."

Teaching in the Digital Age

Earlier this month, the Quick & Ed team discussed (here and here) what schools might look like in the future, as online learning continues to take hold. Today, the Washington Post takes a look at how virtual learning changes how teachers teach. According to the article, online teaching jobs can be highly competitive - because of the flexibility in hours, but also because of how it changes the role of the teacher. As the program director for Virginia's virtual schools stated, "People are intrigued and realize its pure teaching--you're not worrying about cafeteria duty."

Thursday, July 24, 2008

The Baby Borrowers Last Night

The back-to-back episodes of The Baby Borrowers last night proved my earlier assertion that the show was not about teens taking care of children, but about teens taking care of themselves and their relationships.

Although Baby Borrowers intends to act as a deterrent to would-be teen parents (the show's slogan is "it's not parenting; it's birth control"), the reality is that the teens, as parents, are getting better. They've learned how and when to apply discipline, if still a little raw at both, and they're practicing the skills of running a family household—cooking healthy meals, going to work and balancing budgets, imposing timeouts and bedtimes, etc. If anything, the parenting/ household portions of the episodes show the opposite of what the producers intend. When called upon, the teens mostly step up.

The couples, in contrast, are failing one by one. Daton and Morgan came on the show as a way to test the strength of their relationship, so it was no huge surprise when he became the first of the teens to leave. Kelly has deep doubts about her relationship to Austin, and they are now in limbo, with a promise to break up after the completion of the entire experiment. It just makes for awkward television. Poor David, whose real-life parents are going through a divorce, to have to watch the drama and feel the tension between Austin and Kelly.

Even the couples with prior difficulties have rebounded. Kelsey and Sean seem to have settled in, and they're barely seen in the two hours of show last night (which, in this drama-laced show, means they're doing just fine). Cory and Alicea did the best job of parenting seen yet with troubled teen Sam. After Sam dumped all of Alicea's clothes on the floor, the teen "parents" stood strong, together, against the angst-ridden boy. And Sasha and Jordan returned to their place at the top of the couple/ parent rankings. When one member of each couple was treated to a visit by a friend, Jordan and his best friend hung out with Sasha too. Tellingly, Daton and his friend went to a skating rink, alone, to commiserate about Morgan.

I'm glad the show is almost over—they take care of the elderly next week, before presumably some type of wrap-up—because NBC has made this a painful ride. Unlike the original show, lauded as a success across the pond, NBC made this just another teen drama roller coaster. By selecting struggling couples made up of teens that had never worked a day in their life, they thought they'd get instances of bad parenting. Instead, they got pouty teens and malfunctioning couples who just happened to be babysitting. It's not birth control; it's couples counseling.

Wednesday, July 23, 2008

That's Funny, But Not Ha-Ha Funny

The Fordham Institute's Liam Julian has vowed to spend his entire summer pounding out overlong responses to this blog, so that we won't "let fly with a barrage of blog blather like none yet seen, safe in [our] assumption that [our] ill-founded fulminations would go unopposed."
Okay.....first of all, it's really a disservice to William F. Buckley's memory to mock his prose style this way. The man's been gone less than six months, show some respect. Also, Liam's posts would be better if he knew what he was talking about. In a lengthy anti-affirmative action screed, he says:

Thus, we have this: Yale accepts a black student whose qualifications are average for the University of Michigan, Michigan accepts a black student whose resume would be appropriate at Florida State, and Florida State fills its classes with black and Latino students whose credentials reflect those of their community college peers.
Yes, imagine what would happen if Florida State made a practice of admitting academically less qualified black and Latino students, some with SAT scores in the 900s or below. Oh wait, we don't have to imagine, because Education Sector published an entire policy paper on exactly that topic just three months ago. It turns out that black students at FSU do just as well as white students. Last year, they did better. Why? Because the university has a great program in place designed to help first-generation college students succeed. Liam has a degree from FSU, yet seems not to have noticed this. Must have been too busy watching the football team slide into scandal and mediocrity.

Then there's this gem from an earlier post about "theory" and the practice of teaching:

Is it not true that much of this theory and methodology is a relatively modern invention, one that did not exist a half-century ago, when fine teachers surely did?

If my calculations are correct, a half-century ago was in 1958. John Dewey published Democracy and Education in 1916. The first half of the 20th century (i.e. the pre-1958 half) featured a series of intense ideological debates about the meaning and practice of public education. Whole educational movements rose and fell, each grounded in theory, with a significant impact on schooling for millions of students. How do I know this? Because I--unlike, apparently, Liam--read Left Back: A Century of Failed School Reforms, by noted education historian Diane Ravitch. Liam shouldn't have any trouble finding a copy--Ravitch is on the Fordham Institute's Board of Trustees.

Suggestions for summer reading: less blogging and God and Man at Yale, more education policy and history.

Get Thee Some Graduate Students!

In Sunday’s New York Times Magazine, Emily Bazelon writes about the recent shift among school districts to integration policies based on economic status - not race - in light of last June's Supreme Court decision. Bazelon's review of the research on the impact of integration on student achievement highlights a serious problem for integration proponents - there just isn't much good research out there showing student achievement benefits from integration policies, whether they’re based on race or economic status.

I, unlike some people, find the logic behind creating “middle class schools” compelling – concentrated poverty brings with it a host of problems at the school-level, including fewer school resources and less qualified teachers, that tend to exacerbate any problems students are bringing with them from home. But I have yet to see any convincing research to show that busing students to create middle class schools will improve student achievement, at least as measured on standardized assessments.

In Bazelon’s article, for example, she cites research showing that low-income students in middle class schools score better than low-income students in majority low-income schools. That’s interesting, and indicates that concentrated poverty may have an effect on achievement, but it’s impossible to disentangle those results from other things that may be happening—the students in the middle class school may also live in more socioeconomically mixed neighborhoods, or, while they may qualify as low-income, their parents may have higher education levels or hold full-time (albeit low-paying) jobs. This type of anecdotal evidence leaves a lot to be desired, and leaves those who support integration policies with few genuine facts to grab hold of.

The evidence supporting gains beyond test scores, such as graduation rates, college attendance, and employment, also hint to positive outcomes from integration plans, but are frustratingly weak when it comes to research design. METCO, for example, Boston’s long-running integration program, which buses students from the city into neighboring suburban districts, reports that 87 percent of METCO students attend college, compared with 54 percent of Boston public school students as a whole. That’s great, but considering that there are 12,000 students on the waitlist for METCO and students are assigned to the program by lottery, why hasn’t anyone conducted a study comparing the students randomly selected to participate in METCO with those who were not selected? The results from that study would be taken much more seriously and would hold up better to scrutiny than simply reporting comparisons with Boston’s general student population.

Integration proponents' biggest hurdle may not be the recent Supreme Court case, instead, it may be the lack of rigorous research on integration and student achievement. While KIPP and other charter school networks are investing in longitudinal studies on student outcomes, those who would like to see resources spent on integration, rather than building new schools, will need to pursue similarly rigorous research efforts. If they don’t, public support for integration policies may wane in favor of efforts to create new neighborhood schools, segregated or not.

Self-Tying Logical Knots

Reporting from the recent AFT convention, Sherman Dorn makes an important point w/r/t a discussion led by Susan Ohanian (who is waaaay out there on the fringes of anti-NCLB absolutism, to the point where she recently took to the pages of Kappan to denounce the NEA for being too moderate on No Child):

Ohanian worried about the statement by Obama that "the single most important factor in determining a child's achievement is not the color of their skin or where they come from; it's not who their parents are or how much money they have. It's who their teacher is." Ohanian argued that this statement is rhetoric that sets up blaming teachers for all sorts of problems they are not responsible for. A few minutes later, she claimed that the real danger of high-stakes accountability was the destruction of children's imaginations and the creation of a compliant workforce. But there's a logical inconsistency here: how can schools create worker robots if they are not powerful in shaping the lives of children?

I worry (and I said towards the end of the event) that Ohanian's criticism undercut arguments about the importance of the public sphere. You can say that teachers are not crucial to children's lives, but then it's hard to argue that schools should be well-funded. You can say that teachers are not crucial, but then it's hard to argue against all sorts of problematic policy proposals that take authority away from teachers or that position teachers' professional judgment as irrelevant. Ohanian was nodding in acknowledgment at the time, so I think (or I hope) she knows that her impromptu remarks were not consistent with either her deeper views of schooling or that of most teachers.

Dorn is being entirely too generous; this inconsistency is deliberate and sits at the heart of everything Ohanian and her ilk have to say. At the risk of being simplistic, one can divide attitudes about public education within the policy sphere into three basic camps. The first is "Public education doesn't work so let's get rid of it." This is your arch-conservative John Derbyshire-type stuff, which consists of various loosely coupled theories involving IQ determinism, the miracle of free markets, the evils of taxation and organized labor, etc. It enjoys durable appeal in some circles but is almost wholly marginalized in policymaking, owing to the fact that it's completely dumb.

The second is the basic reformist position: "Public education works so let's make it work better." It's the view that informs this blog, one that begins with a belief in the importance of public schools as tremendously vital and fundamentally egalitarian institutions, but proceeds to a fairly critical stance that's centered on ideas like increased accountability for results. It's sympathetic to the need for more educational resources but skeptical that the money we're spending now is being put to maximum use.

While the two positions don't have equal value (in that the first is wrong and the second is right) both have the advantage of logical consistency. If you really believe half of all students are uneducatable and we'd be better of in an all-vouchers-all-the-time world, than destroying public education as we know it makes sense. Similarly, if you believe that schools and teachers have great potential to help students, particularly disadvantaged students, then we should invest in them while also tying that investment to real accountability for student learning.

Then there's third position--the Ohanian position--which is really less a coherent position at all than a set of attitudes and individual agenda items rooted in defensiveness and a desire to maintain established institutions and arrangements as they are. To be clear, some of this defensiveness is quite justified -- there really are first position adherents out there who wish public education harm. But much of it boils down to the idea that while public education needs substantially more funding and teachers deserve much more respect (both of which ideas are, in and of themselves, true) it's unreasonable to suggest that either the funding or the respect ought to be accompanied by any commensurate expectation of enhanced, concretely defined educational results. Or, similarly, the idea that we have to protect children from policies that will either deliberately or inadveratently turn them into dead-eyed grist for the capitalist machine a la Another Brick in the Wall, Part 2, yet at the same time schools have little or no upside potential to help economically disadvantaged students learn enough to lead a fulfilling, productive life.

This position is based on no core beliefs regarding the efficacy of public education, but rather shifts back and forth on that question depending on the issue at hand. Of course it's possible to be too optimistic about what schools can do in the face of large social problems, but the Ohanian position seems unwilling to give an inch here, or admit under any circumstances that a not-insignficant percentage of schools and teachers could be much better than they are.

Tuesday, July 22, 2008

Fear for Your Daughter's Virtue

"Boys crisis" promoter Richard Whitmire has a piece in the Chronicle of Higher Ed offering a new reason to be upset about the higher education gender imbalance: it's turning college girls into, um, women of easy virtue, allegedly because of "what biologists refer to as the operational sex ratio, which in the animal kingdom refers to the changes in mating habits that occur when one sex outnumbers the other." Sherman Dorn does a good job of pointing out the numerous flaws in this argument here (see also Sara Mead from a couple of years ago on the same topic here). I'll just note that this once again raises the issue of affirmative action for men, a terrible discriminatory practice that colleges and universities should abandon.

Race-based affirmative action is a complex issue; on balance I support it for reasons explained here. But whether you're pro or con, I think everyone would agree that it evens out the racial distribution of students among colleges. Because minority students are less likely to attend well-funded schools and less likely to get strong college prep curricula in high school, on average they enter the college admissions pool with weaker credentials than white students, and thus end up disproportionately attending less selective colleges. Affirmative action counteracts this, with the result being within-college racial/ethnic makeups that are more representative of the college student body as a whole. Crucially, race-based affirmative action as practiced by selective colleges doesn't hurt non-selective colleges, because it simply brings the racial/ethnic mix into more of a balance.

This isn't true for gender-based affirmative action, because the underlying rationale is very different. Race-based affirmative action makes up for numerous historical and contemporary inequities that obviously don't apply to men. When it comes to gender, however, balance is everything and the only thing, with colleges scrambling to avoid an allegedly catastrophic 60/40 female-to-male ratio which somehow causes previously chaste female collegians to behave like extras in a Motley Crue video.

But gender preferences at a given selective college do nothing to fix the overall problem of more women in college than men. Instead, they merely push that problem down the higher education food chain, from the selective colleges to the non-selectives. If a selective college rejects a more qualified woman in favor of a less qualified man, she's still going to college somewhere. So the net result is that that less selective institutions that by definition don't have as much leverage to shape their class makeup end up having to deal with the problem of bacchanals in the dorm rooms or what have you. In other words, gender-based affirmative action isn't just immoral and possibly illegal under Title IX, it's also selfish.

Plus, I really don't get the logic: colleges are essentially saying they have to not admit women because otherwise women won't want to go there. Isn't this problem inherently self-correcting? If high female/male ratios are a turn-off for women, won't fewer women apply to colleges where the ratio is out of whack? It's kind of like what Yogi Berra said about the restaurant that nobody goes to anymore because it's too crowded.

Monday, July 21, 2008

Forget Something?

The recent New York State Commission on Higher Education report contains a number of recommendations for making New York public colleges and universities globally competitive, and has some good ideas for improving connections with K-12 education and workforce development. But much of the report sounds like the arms race rhetoric common in higher education, and misses out on an important purpose of colleges and universities: educating undergraduates.

The report includes several ideas on ways to improve the research standing of certain NY state universities, including devoting more funds to support research, recruiting “top flight” faculty and graduate students, and enhancing entrance requirements (e.g. raising SAT scores) at these institutions. In fact, the 100-page report mentions “research” a total of 175 times.

“Learning” is mentioned 18 times, “Undergraduate” 11 times. And teaching? Twice.

This isn’t to say that there aren’t valuable recommendations in the report, and ones that benefit undergraduates. The proposal for a seamless transfer system—allowing students to move from one state university to another without risking losing credit hours—is particularly good. But the focus of the report is clearly on research and graduate-level studies.

While US News rankings - much of which are based on the research and "entrance requirements" the Commission seeks to enhance - are seen as the marker of success in much of higher education, the New York State Commission on Higher Education would have done well to eschew that rhetoric in favor of what will likely become an area of increasing concern—improving the quality of undergraduate education.

Friday, July 18, 2008

The NEA Wants Your Stories

I subscribe to the NEA's email list, and the latest one had this eye-catching opening:
Have You Been Caught on YouTube?
A student videotaped a teacher at Malibu High School who lost control of the class and raised his voice while students laughed at him. Another video showed an angry high school teacher forcing a student to stand for the National Anthem by yanking his chair out from under him. Outrageous classroom moments are being captured on cell phone cameras and broadcast on YouTube for the entire world to see. Has this happened to you or any of your colleagues? Share your story and be considered for an upcoming NEA Today article.
They direct you to a discussion board that's a little more on message, but I really don't understand why the NEA would want to collect stories about poor or violent teachers caught on tape.

The Math of Merit Pay

Bured in yesterday's Ed Week write-up ($) of McCain's speech was a quote that nicely sums up the common concerns over merit pay:

Bettye Oldham, a retired teacher from Cincinnati, said she had mixed feelings about the merit-pay proposal.

“I think it’s a good idea if it’s run correctly,” she said. “But you can’t judge teachers the way you can judge manufacturing companies.” Some students come to school with “issues that prevent them from learning,” she said, which can make it harder for teachers to reach them.

I picture what Ms. Oldham might look like, and I can see her mulling the pros and cons of merit pay. She's probably worried that it would reduce teachers to nothing more than cogs on an assembly line, but also understands the implicit logic that good doctors and lawyers make more money than bad ones. Teachers, on the other hand, are paid only by credentials--all teachers in the same district with a bachelor's degree and 12 years experience, for instance, are paid the exact same amount no matter their talent or specialty area.

Merit pay seeks to measure some of the work teachers do. While the precise math is a little too complicated for this blog, in essence it looks like a fairly straightforward algebra problem:

Student achievement = age + prior achievement + student demographic information + teacher quality + measurement error

A common argument against merit pay, and the one repeated by Ms. Oldham, is that there are too many human elements for the measurement of teaching. But that argument overlooks even the simple version of the merit pay equation. Race, income and prior achievement are all factored in, and the error term captures all those things that are not predictable--a student's situation at home, whether they had a good breakfast, whether it's too hot or cold, etc.--all things that surely affect the student's score but are not measurable.

It might seem a little too whiz-bang to trust the capabilities of modern statistical computer programs, but mathematicians far greater than I are working to refine the exact statistical equations. We've made giant strides in our ability to compute the value an individual teacher adds to student learning. Let's not let fear of complex, modern math get in the way of promising reform.

Update: Fred Klonsky responds with the "human element" argument. He's making my point for me though, because it really goes back to a fear of assessment of teachers' work. We are comfortable measuring a baseball player's batting average, even if they had a bad breakfast, a rough flight the night before, or an argument with their spouse. In fact, their results are published the next morning in your daily paper. I can't imagine A-Rod explaining poor results on the field with his off-field Madonnna shenanigans. There are "human elements" to everything in life.

Thursday, July 17, 2008

Un-Advanced

John McCain spent a lot of time in his NAACP speech in Cincinnati yesterday talking about the many teacher reforms he'd put in place--performance pay, a greater role for principals in staffing matters, and peer evaluations, among them. If McCain's education advisors had been on the ball, they would have told the presumptive Republican presidential nominee that those very reforms are already in place in Cincinnati, with the blessing of the local teacher union, no less. The question is, What have the reforms wrought there?

Where's Rick, Someone Call Rick

"All I can say is that President Weingarten's early signals do no credit to Al Shanker's legacy."

McCain Speaks

In his long-awaited (if you're an education policy person, which admittedly narrows the field somewhat) education speech, Senator McCain said:

We should also offer more choices to those who wish to become teachers. Many thousands of highly qualified men and women have great knowledge, wisdom, and experience to offer public school students. But a monopoly on teacher certification prevents them from getting that chance. You can be a Nobel Laureate and not qualify to teach in most public schools today. They don't have all the proper credits in educational "theory" or "methodology" -- all they have is learning and the desire and ability to share it. If we're putting the interests of students first, then those qualifications should be enough.

I'm generally sympathetic to policies aimed at opening up the teaching profession, because it seems clear that success in the classroom is a function of multiple factors (experience, subject matter knowledge, pedagogical skills, training, work ethic, verbal ability, general smartness, innate talent for teaching) some of which are given undue weight under the current system and some of which are basically ignored. The world's greatest teacher would have all of these qualities in spades, but of course such people are few and far between and it's apparent from the track record of initiatives like Teach for America and some of the better alt-cert programs that people can be reasonably successful with less of some things (experience, training) if they have enough of the others.

That said, I hate this sentence: "They don't have all the proper credits in educational "theory" or "methodology" -- all they have is learning and the desire and ability to share it." Putting words like theory and methodology between contemptuous quotes (shouldn't we invent a new punctuation mark to distinguish those from regular quotes?) is ridiculous. Teaching is an extremely complicated endeavor. A teacher's ability to share knowledge (which is in itself an extremely reductive conception of what teaching actually means) is naturally going to be improved by a solid understanding of theory and methods. Of course some ed schools teach those things badly or over-emphasize them, but that's no reason to dismiss them out of hand.

This is garden variety anti-intellectualism and doesn't speak well of Senator McCain's approach to policy or other matters. One could imagine, for example, that having a lot of knowledge about war and a desire to conduct wars but lacking a larger theoretical understanding of geo-politics and the methods of statecraft might lead one to actively support a ruinous foreign war and then continue to support it even after its ruinousness has become obvious for all to see.

In theory.

Realism and Anonymity

Thoughts on a couple of recent blog-related discussions:

First, I endorse Eduwonk's take on NAEP scores and their meaning in relation to recent state-specific assessment results. The recent dramatic test score gains in New York and now Maryland have produced a spate of circular reasoning on the part of the "NCLB is a conspiracy to destroy public education and pave the way for Wal-Mart to take over the schools" crowd. That argument holds that the pace of improvement and narrowing of class-based achievement disparities envisioned under the law are absurd and unrealistic--thus, the conspiracy. As evidence, they note that such improvement has never happened before. Now that it's actually happening, the argument is, apparently, that it can't actually be happening, because it's never happened before. Or something.  

Second, it's clarifying to read Eduwonkette's back-and-forth with Jay Greene. The basic problem is that she's jumbling up a discussion of peer review with a discussion of motive and and anonymity. Here she puts blog posts, think tank publications, and academic research on a single continuum of "credibility," asserting that peer-reviewed research is most credible, think stuff less so, and blogs least of all.  But this misses the obvious point that credibility and the processes used to ensure it are highly dependent on purpose. 

The purpose of academic research is to inform, to add to a collective body of knowledge. As a result, credibility assurance processes have been developed that make sense given that purpose, primarily peer review and transparency of sources and methods. Motive and authorship aren't as important--when I read an article in an academic journal, I'm less concerned with who did the work than how they did it, where the data came from and what methods were used for analysis. It wouldn't really bother me if authorship were attributed to "An assistant professor at Columbia University" as opposed to an actual named person; the format of academic research is such that the things I need to know to judge credibility are right there in black and white, or embedded in the journal's publicly stated peer review process.

The purpose of blogs, by contrast, as with all opinion writing, is to persuade. And the motive to persuade always comes from somewhere--agendas, convictions, ideologies, etc. Unlike academic research, opinions and arguments can't be evaluated purely on their own terms. And this is reflected in the credibility-assurance practices of organizations that are in the business of publishing opinions. Op-eds in the Washington Post, for example, always have a little blurb at the end telling the reader who the author is. There's a reason: Imagine if you read a column arguing that climate change isn't such a big problem after all, written by Jane Smith. If you saw that Jane was a p.r. flack for ExxonMobil, you'd take it one way. If you saw that she was the president of the Sierra Club, you'd take it another, and for good reason. Same words, different meaning. 

Motives and affiliations matter, particularly in the realm of opinion. That's why respectable publications like Education Week don't publish anonymous op-eds. Heck, they don't even publish anonymous letters to the editor. Why they've abandoned this logical, time-honored standard when it comes to their officially-endorsed blogs, I really don't understand. 


Wednesday, July 16, 2008

McCain Goes Virtual for Education

Today, during his speech to the NAACP, presumptive Republican nominee John McCain released his education plan. And, for a man who only last week was learning to go online (sorry, couldn't resist), it's a strong start.

John McCain Supports Expanding Virtual Learning By Reforming The "Enhancing Education Through Technology Program." John McCain will target $500 million in current federal funds to build new virtual schools and support the development of online course offerings for students. These courses may be for regular coursework, for enhancement, or for dual enrollment into college.

John McCain Will Allocate $250 Million Through A Competitive Grant Program To Support States That Commit To Expanding Online Education Opportunities. States can use these funds to build virtual math and science academies to help expand the availability of AP Math, Science, and Computer Sciences courses, online tutoring support for students in traditional schools, and foreign language courses.

John McCain Will Offer $250 Million For Digital Passport Scholarships To Help Students Pay For Online Tutors Or Enroll In Virtual Schools. Low-income students will be eligible to receive up to $4,000 to enroll in an online course, SAT/ACT prep course, credit recovery or tutoring services offered by a virtual provider. Providers could range from other public schools, virtual charter schools, home school parents utilizing virtual schooling resources or district or state sponsored virtual schools. The Department of Education would competitively award the funds to a national scholarship administrator who would manage the student applications, monitoring, and evaluation of providers.
I'm pleased to see Senator McCain up the ante on the $120 million virtual schooling innovation fund that I proposed last year. One important emphasis that is missing from Senator McCain's plan is a focus on innovation. While his fund as proposed would likely spur the development of more virtual learning experiences, it would not capitalize on digital learning's unique potential for rapid innovation and improvement. I guess it's ok for the federal government to provide scholarships, but a much more highly leveraged federal role would research how digital learning could improve instruction and then, importantly, rapidly spread these improvements. As I recommended in my report Virtual High Schools and Innovation in Public Education:

Each grantee would have to develop a plan to pilot test, evaluate, and replicate a project in one or more virtual school programs within two years. Over time, grantees with the strongest records of having their innovations adopted by others would get preference for additional funding. All materials, methods, technologies, and data developed through the fund would be available for adoption via a public and freely available open source model.
Senator Obama, who has leveraged the Internet extensively in his campaign, is largely silent on these issues. Perhaps he will consider enhancing his education plan.

Tuesday, July 15, 2008

Too Weird for The Wire

A little over four months ago, after weeks of dutiful episode summaries and commentary, I posted a short piece about the final episode of The Wire, promising to follow up with more. Alas, I never got around to it, and the guilt has been haunting me ever since.  So, as a gesture of contrition to our loyal readership, I've written a whole magazine article in this month's Washington Monthly about a group of drug dealers from West Baltimore--essentially the real-life guys from The Wire--who are defending themselves against a massive federal drugs/weapons/conspiracy/murder indictment using constitutional fundamentalist legal theories developed by white supremacists, gun nuts, Timothy McVeigh militia / patriot crazy people, etc. Featuring cameo appearances by Geraldo Rivera, Toby Keith, and former heavyweight boxing champion Hasim Rahman, plus some really terrible rap lyrics. 

Set The Research Free!

While Jay Greene and Eduwonkette are going back and forth about peer-reviewed versus think thank research, I’m wondering how you get your hands on all this great, peer-reviewed research in the first place.

Last week, the journal Nature announced that it was offering researchers the option of making their publications available for free online. This allows people beyond the elite world of academic institutions to gain access to this research - a smart move for researchers who want their work read and utilized beyond the small world of academics who subscribe to these journals. As a field that seeks to provide information to people outside of academia—teachers, school leaders, non-profit organizations—the education research world should be a leader in providing free, online access to academic articles. Instead, much high-quality, peer-reviewed research is locked away in a multitude of expensive journals with little attempt to make the research affordable or easily accessible.

Yesterday, for example, I tried to access an article in a peer-reviewed education research publication. I tried getting the article through an education research database that Education Sector subscribes to—a database that is supposed to provide us with full text articles from this particular journal. But, as it turns out, there is a 12-month delay in getting articles from this journal. In order to get access to the most recent research, I would need to pay $30 for one article, which may or may not provide what I need—I don’t know because I only have the abstract on which to base my purchasing decision.

Note to academia: this is not an effective method for getting people to read or use your research.

I guess I’ll just have to turn to research from another think tank or policy organization—it may not be peer reviewed, but it’s accessible. And in a world with online access to nearly everything, that just may be more important.

Monday, July 14, 2008

First Come First Serve

Per below, the comments on today's student debt column are really a must-read, here's one:

Senior Citizensin Student Loan Debt and credit
I have rearely , if ever, seen anything written about the plight of many senior citizens who carry old student loan debt. I graduated university in 1985 [ some loans dating from ‘81]. My loan debt ballooned because of the interest,yes, but more importantly, I had a family crisis [ terminally ill child]and I was physically and emotionally unable to begin to address the issies. I WAS in contact with the banks and the USDE. At one point [ late 80s] I eas even willing to collect soda cans and bottles [ that’s all I could do because I was homeless] but I was told “that’s not good enough.” It wasn’t until I get good jobs inthe late 90s and 2000 that I could begin to pay anything. Now I am living on ONLY Social Security; I AM paying on my loans, but the staggering sum of interest accrued is enough to send me to cardiac arrest. I wish there were some relief! If there is any will someone PLEASE tell me!

Dee DeMusis, at 10:35 am EDT on July 14, 2008
Now, I know for a fact that there are journalists out there who read this blog. Come one--this piece writes itself! You've got impoverished senior citizens AND the health care crisis AND uncaring student loan companies, all wrapped up in a compelling personal story that provides a fresh angle on a hot issue. Your lede's already written! Track this poor woman down and take the rest of the week off, your work is done!

Fat Cats

Kevin pre-empted my post on today's DC Examiner, but there's even more to it than Kevin described.

Today's story gave us the base salary and other compensation for eight local superintendents, including Jack Dale, superintendent of Fairfax County. Dale will make $292,000 in base salary this year, plus a $62,000 retirement contribution. He runs an agency responsible for educating 165,000 students with 13,090 teachers and 26,778 total staff members with a budget over $2 billion. Just down the road from Dale and Fairfax County schools is George Mason University. Its president, Alan G. Merten, made $642,500 ($) in total compensation in 2006-7 including a car and a house. Merten's school educates 30,000 students a year and has a $750 million budget. Who's better paid, Dale or Merten?

The Examiner piece also provides its own rebuttal. It lists eight local superintendent salaries, and all earn total compensation packages between $250 and $350,000. Eight separate school boards determined the appropriate compensation level for their chief executive, and they all offered salaries in this range. This suggests the salaries were market-based.

The story today wasn't an isolated incident. The New York Times ran a piece last week along the exact same lines. It chronicled the severance package of Barbara Trzeszkowski, employed in Keansburg, New Jersey for 38.5 years, first as a long-time teacher and then as superintendent. Keansburg is known as an "Abbott district," so-called for its eligibility for state funds targeting extremely needy schools. Buried in the article mainly critical of her financial windfall was this quote:

Joe Hazeldine, who was chairman of the Keansburg school board and a member of the personnel committee at the time Ms. Trzeszkowski’s most recent contract was negotiated, defended it recently from his home in North Carolina. He said Ms. Trzeszkowski was “worth every single penny she earned, if not more.”

“She’s a remarkable administrator,” Mr. Hazeldine said. “She took Keansburg from the bottom of the Abbott districts to the top. Our college acceptance rate quadrupled. We had kids going to Ivy League schools. That doesn’t just happen. How do you put a price on that?

In education, apparently, we must.

Shameful

One of the things you learn when writing for newspapers and magazines--something that's not at all obvious otherwise--is that the process by which a finished package of article and headline comes together actually consists of multiple, semi-connected parts. Basically you come to an agreement with your editor about the essential thrust and structure of the piece, write it, work with the editor on modifications etc., until it's finished. Then, in an entirely separate process, somebody, often a separate third party, comes up with the title and accompanying blurb--the "hed" and "dek" in publishingese. Then if you're lucky enough to get your piece on the cover, somebody--possibly another person--comes up with another headline, accompanying blurb, etc. Oftentimes you don't even find out what your article is going to be titled until it's published.

This process can produce some strange juxtapositions, particularly when the various parties involved are working from different imperatives. The editor, if she's good at her job, will be concerned with matters such as clarity, logic, concision, fairness, persuasiveness, and accuracy. The headline-writer, by contrast, tends to be more focused on coming up with something pithy and attention-grabbing. And this is doubly true, or more so, for the cover headline-writer, where degrees of grabbiness translate directly into circulation and sales.

Unfortunately, the system can sometimes go awry and result in a "telephone"-like iterative process of escalating sensationalism, as with this piece in today's DC Examiner, which looks at how much money the superintendents of the area's large public school districts are paid. Basically, they do pretty well in the grand scheme of things, making $200,000 to $400,000 per year plus benefits. Which isn't nothing, but as the article notes, these are immensely difficult jobs that involve running some of the largest school districts in the United States. There's not a single quote in the article from anyone who thinks they're overpaid. And as an accompanying sidebar notes, their salaries are chump change compared to what the leaders of big, locally-based private corporations make, i.e. the $31 million pulled down by the CEO of Lockheed Martin.

The hed for this article is "Packages for schools chiefs full of bonuses, lucrative retirement" along with a semi-compensatory dek: "Benefits commensurate with job's long hours, criticism, officials say." This teeters on the edge of sensationalism but I can sort of live with it. The cover, by contrast, is a whole different story: "Fat cat edu-crats: High pay, lavish perks enrich schools chiefs"

That's just shameful. It's journalism of the lowest order. It does a disservice to the author and frankly embarrasses everyone involved with the Examiner, which is a free paper distributed in boxes around the DC metro area. The vast majority of passers-by who glance at that cover aren't going to flip through to page 4 to read the whole article with the lack of criticism, the Lockheed comparison, and all the rest. They're just going to mentally file it away as one more piece of evidence that public education is inefficient and ridiculous, that the government is over-taxing them and wasting their money on feckless bureaucrats. They'll be a little more filled with unjustified anger toward the public sector. They'll "know" one more thing that's actually wrong. All so the Examiner can sell a little more advertising, never mind the truth.