Friday, October 31, 2008
Don't Waiver
What's really important to understand is the federalism at play here in higher education finance. The maintenance of effort provision applies only to public institutions, so let's stick with a discussion of them. Public sector tuition gets set in different ways depending on the state. Some states let institutions set tuition rates either outright or by default. Some have governor-appointed boards do the rate-setting, and some state legislatures even do it themselves. The point is that legislatures and governors have a lot of say in tuition policy, even if they prefer to play the part of unwilling accomplice. In my home state of Iowa, we have a Board of Regents that is governor-appointed. They set tuition policies for the three state universities. They end up caught in the middle of a constant push and pull for power by the universities and the legislature. The legislature thinks the Regents coddle the universities, while campus officials cry out that the Regents are in the bag for the legislature.
These things matter when it comes to something like the maintenance of effort provision, because state governors and legislatures are crying bloody murder that the feds are having too much of a role in higher education. See the NGA's press releases opposing the provision before it became law here, here, here, here, and here. Their opposition almost killed it entirely, and they are certainly the reason it became almost entirely toothless. The law always had a provision allowing states to use five-year rolling averages in its calculation (so states, your budget cuts of the early 2000s actually lower that average now), but it got tied to such a tiny tiny sum of money that it became effectively meaningless. The total money at stake for 2008 is $66 million, a drop in the bucket when you consider that we spend 242 times that, $16 billion, on the federal Pell Grant program. State governments spend much more than that.
Governors and legislatures are the willing victims in this instance. States would like federal policymakers to believe they've done their share in funding higher education. And it's partly true. An unreported fact is that states provide almost exactly the same revenue per full-time equivalent student that they did in 1980 (in constant 2007 dollars). Of course, this does not account for rapidly expanding costs in other areas, especially health care, but the problem isn't just state spending, as is commonly reported elsewhere. The real problem is tuition.
While states have managed to hold the line on state expenditures, they have been unable to hold back tuition at public colleges and universities. According to the states' own numbers, from 1982 to 2007 tuition increased 190% over inflation. Much as we'd like to blame institutions for coddling undergraduates with fancy dorms and expensive perks like chefs and new-age gyms, state governments have been complicit as well. Their desire to compete with private institutions has caused them to ignore equity concerns and spend scarce funds on ever-increasing merit aid, which quadrupled from 1996 to 2006.
Enter the feds. The federal government has no role in setting tuition whatsoever. Its role in higher education is limited to providing financial aid for needy students, getting dollars into the hands of researchers, and providing tax breaks for donations to non-profit foundations that are more and more essential to higher education. But they feel the pressure of rising tuition costs nonetheless. They feel it from parents during election time, but they also feel it from organizations like the NGA, which is critical of how little a percentage of tuition Pell Grants now cover.
The meager maintenance of effort provision is a good start. Secretary Spellings should quickly dismiss this latest attempt to skirt responsibility.
Schools left out of technological innovation?
Four-Day Weeks
So what’s a state to do? Marc Porter McGee of ConnCan has some interesting ideas here, including cutting overhead and shedding unnecessary contracts. States and districts are going to have to be careful, though, with these decisions about what's necessary— bus driver salaries and facility costs may not seem directly connected to student instruction but if cutting these means cutting school time, less cost means less learning.
Thursday, October 30, 2008
Losing Ground?
It's a big dramatic statement, and the New York Times jumped on it in an editorial that ran yesterday, saying:
Americans should be deeply alarmed by new data showing that the country is continuing to lose ground educationally to its competitors abroad. The United States once had the world’s top high-school graduation rate. It has now fallen to 13th place behind countries like South Korea, the Czech Republic and Slovenia. Worse still, a new study from the Education Trust, a nonpartisan foundation, finds that this is the only country in the industrial world where young people are less likely than their parents to graduate high school.
Time magazine picked it up in a story that ran today, saying:
The U.S. is the only industrialized nation in the world where children are now less likely to receive a high school diploma than their parents were, according to an Oct. 23 report by the Education Trust, a children's advocacy group based in Washington.
Two things to keep in mind. First, the statistic comes from the latest batch of education numbers released by the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). The OECD is indeed a collection of industrialized countries. But it's not an organization of all industrialized countries. The table from which this number was pulled includes 29 OECD member countries and six additional "partner economies." It's true that, by one measure, the U.S. is the only member country with a generational decline in high school degree attainment (more on this below). But the comparison list doesn't include Japan, China, India, Taiwan, Iran, South Africa, Argentina and Venezuela, among others. There may be differences of opinion about the meaning of "industrialized," but I'm pretty sure Japan qualifies. Whether high school attainment is stable or rising in every other industrialized country, I don't know. In any case, the phrase "only industrialized country in the world" is over-broad.
Wednesday, October 29, 2008
College Gets More Expensive, Part MCMXVII
Sweating the Big Stuff
Monday, October 27, 2008
100% or...What?
Weighted Student Funding
I don’t think weighted student funding is a bad idea, necessarily. But it’s worth noting that we’re sitting in a cautionary tale. The District of Columbia Public Schools used a weighted student formula for several of its most dysfunctional years before it was abandoned by Fordham favorite Michelle Rhee. There’s a good summary of the system from 2006 here. Among the pitfalls:
An unintended consequence of the WSF implementation is that certain key staffing decisions have become uneven and inconsistent across schools, such that DCPS cannot tell parents with absolute certainty what each school is providing for their students. Full autonomy regarding how dollars are spent has led to 150 different decisions to determine an adequate ratio for counselors, appropriate levels of support in literacy and numeracy, and how (or even if) content areas such as art, music, and PE are delivered to students.
The report concludes that the weighted student formula did not to do enough to “ensure that critical educational resources — not simply dollars — are distributed consistently and equitably.”
Seven Percent
A new Center on Education Policy report found that seven percent of all Title I schools in the country are now in "restructuring," meaning they were unable to make AYP for five consecutive years. Think about that number for a moment. Seven percent. We hear all the time how awful NCLB is and how it identifies too many schools as failing, but seven percent of persistent underperformers really isn't very high at all.
The same report recorded two other important findings. First, about twenty percent of schools going through restructuring are able to make AYP the following year. This is a good sign of progress. Second, nine in ten schools in restructuring choose options like extra professional development focused on school improvement, on-site technical assistance with more intense support and monitoring, and on-site leadership coaches or facilitators. These aren't exactly the drastic measures we hear about from the media.
Special Ed Vouchers
Iowa Student Loans
This weekend's report outlined the dubious practices of Iowa Student Loan, including that it:
- paid employees bonuses based on loan volume
- paid colleges based on the number of borrowers
- falsely marketed private loans as the lowest-cost options
- steered students into private loans at the expense of cheaper federal loans with better repayment terms
- compared itself in market share and price offerings to for-profit lenders
This is a real problem in a state where students at each of the state's three public four-year postsecondary institutions all face debt loads above the national average. At the University of Iowa (my alma mater), 61% of students graduate with an average debt load of $22,181. The University of Northern Iowa averages about the same debt load but has a higher percentage of students borrowing. At Iowa State University, the state's land-grant college, graduates average $31,501 in debt. Both Iowa and Iowa State have higher graduate debt burdens that any of their peers.
There's no particular reason why Iowa should have this problem. Its economy has not been hit particularly hard. Its universities are not particularly expensive (the sticker price, that is). And its taxpayers are not particularly frugal. Instead, middling government support for higher education and a student loan corporation more worried about its loan volume and competing with the for-profit sector have slowly made Iowa what it is today: the least affordable higher education state in the country.
Friday, October 24, 2008
Standards
The statement of a candidate that declares my information deemed necessary to protect the qualified experiences of/and the integrity for the School Board's Participation are the 10 years of experience Teaching in the Public Schools and the priorities which process the stature of qualified participation to support the focus of the school's mission and accomplishments that defend the appropriate education-with rights to an adequate education.Another begins like this:
Hello, I am...an inspiring, intelligent, phenomenal Washington with great ambitions, infinite achievements and life long experiences. I was a student in the DC Public School system.Let me be the first to note that this post is immediately preceeded by one in which I condemn the practice of mocking DCPS employees whose jobs are much harder and more important than mine. But there's nothing funny about this, not for DC teachers, graduates, or students currently enrolled. It's deadly serious -- we need to do better.
Thursday, October 23, 2008
Helping
Do all superintendents of big districts get drivers? I had no idea. But just think about the splashy, tell-all book you could write! I'm out of the running as I have no license, but you can find the job posting here. Or if you're in the market for something different, you might apply for the "Critical Response Team."
As it happens, I spent some time at the DCPS offices earlier this year, following members of the Critical Response Team around to see how they work. You can read the story I wrote about it here. In short, their job--their only job--is to help people, all day long, from the crack of dawn until late at night. Most of the people they help are teachers and parents. They also work with administrators, vendors, members of the general public--anyone who picks up the phone or writes an email, they listen to and try to assist. As a result, they deal with literally every thorny, intractable, heartbreaking problem a struggling urban school district can encounter. They work much harder than any Ivy League graduate student, think thank analyst, or blogger I could name. They deserve appreciation, not cheap mockery at the hands of people who should, but don't, know better.
A Fox Guarding The Hen House
Paul Basken's article in today's Chronicle of Higher Education does a great job of laying out the conflicts of interest and perverse incentives in the student loan industry that can lead to unsavory business practices.
As the article describes, a former Sallie Mae employee has filed a lawsuit alleging that the company engaged in fraudulent debt collection practices resulting in ballooning debt for some students. At the heart of the issue is the increasingly interwoven relationships between guarantee agencies and loan companies. Guarantee agencies are supposed to be independent entities that oversee the collection activities of loan companies like Sallie Mae in order to protect both students and the federal government from fraud. But, at least in Sallie Mae's case, this relationship has gotten a little too close for comfort:
Most guarantee agencies are independent of the lenders they oversee. Sallie Mae, however, has a contractual arrangement with USA Funds, the nation’s largest guarantee agency, that gives Sallie Mae extensive financial and operational control over the guarantor that oversees its work. USA Funds, with only about 75 employees of its own, pays Sallie Mae about $250-million a year to provide hundreds of workers to perform most of its guarantor operations. That effectively has left Sallie Mae since 2000 in the role of overseeing its own lending activities.Whether the lawsuit is legitimate or not, it's clear that the safeguards and oversight in the federal loan system designed to protect students and taxpayers have broken down, putting everyone at risk. And this guarantee agency-loan company entanglement is only the beginning - to understand the extent of the troubles, read the whole article here.
Wednesday, October 22, 2008
Governor Palin and Higher Education
Palin's parents -- a high school science teacher and school secretary -- could not afford the college tours so common today. Their four children were expected to, and did, work their way through college."We didn't have the luxury of spending a week driving around visiting universities to see what they're like," said Kim "Tilly" Ketchum, a high school friend. "We were looking at pictures of campuses."This is right, except for the part about "so common today." Remember those weekends when you and your parents spent all that time driving around visiting colleges, getting on each other's nerves? Most people don't, because most students don't apply to lots of colleges, and that's as true now as it was then. In this sense, Palin is just guilty of being an average American college student. (And it does rain a lot in Hilo; I've been there. The Big Island of Hawaii is the most climactically diverse place on the face of the Earth. In a few hours you can drive from the beach through a desert that gets less than 10 inches of rain per year, over a 14,000 foot lava-spewing volcano, through a rain forest, to an area that gets over 125 inches of rain per year--Hilo.)
Palin and Ketchum picked the University of Hawaii at Hilo from a brochure. Only after arriving in Hawaii did they realize that Hilo had rainfall approaching 100 inches a year. "The rain," Ketchum said, "was disturbing.
Double-Take
Combining the two school-rating strategies is the only way to accurately reflect schools' contributions to student learning while preserving the law's commendable commitment to getting low performers up to proficiency and giving schools meaningful incentives to improve the achievement of all students.
Doug Harris of the University of Wisconsin-Madison and I discuss the two-track accountability concept in a commentary we did for Education Week a couple of weeks ago.
Dreary News on Student Debt
It hasn’t always been this way—in the past, salaries helped to mitigate the impact of increases in student debt. According to this report by NCES, while debt levels rose substantially between 1993 and 2000, the monthly payments students were making didn’t take up a significantly higher percent of their salaries, mostly because salary increases were able to keep pace with debt levels. But that’s old data, and it’s likely that students’ debt burdens have increased recently and will only get worse as the economy slows down.
According to FinAid.org’s loan repayment calculator you need a minimum salary of $30,243.60 to afford to repay the average $21,900 loan of a student graduating in 2007. Considering that the average starting salary of a liberal arts graduate in 2007 was $30,502, a lot of graduates will need to consider alternative repayment options to afford their monthly payments. Fortunately federal loans provide those options—income based repayment schedules, extended repayment terms, and graduated repayment. Unfortunately, private student loans don’t, and as students continue to rely on private loan debt, a larger share of their monthly income will be going to pay for their college education.
And alternative repayment plans aren't intended for the average student. According to this NCES report, only 11 percent of 1993 graduates repaid their loans with an alternative repayment plan. The remaining students were on the typical, 10-year schedule. Longer repayment schedules are a great option for students entering low-paying careers, but they also have their downsides—for one, students are repaying loans for up to 30 years of their working lives, they end up paying more in interest, and longer repayment schedules have the potential to make the federal loan program more expensive by extending the amount of time the federal government is subsidizing student interest rates.
As the credit crunch worries higher education administrators, parents, and students about access to loans to attend college, the larger economic woes we’re facing should worry the country about students’ abilities to meeting their growing debt obligations. College graduates are supposed to be one of the biggest economic engines in this country—excessive student loan debt hinders graduates’ abilities to fulfill that role.
Tuesday, October 21, 2008
A Thousand Words
The graph above shows a group of schools in Denver, Colorado, courtesy of the State Department of Education. The numbers have some interesting implications for how to think about poverty, achievement, growth, and accountability in K-12 education.