Friday, September 29, 2006

Kid Lit and thinking about Education

So, when I was trying to think about what books influenced my thinking about education, I had a strange thought. I realized that a substantial share of the books I loved and cherished as a child were about characters who were teachers. My hands-down favorite books as a child were the Anne of Green Gables books by L.M. Montgomery. Anne teaches one-room school in Anne of the Island and a high school principal in Anne of Windy Poplars. Laura in the Little House books also grows up to be a teacher, as does Mable in the Grandma's Attic books, and while Jo Marsh is a writer she and Professor Bhaer run a school for boys in Little Men and Jo's Boys. This isn't surprising: many classic children's books were written at a time when teaching was virtually the only career option available for middle-class women, so as these female characters (two of whom are based on real people) grow up (they all started their series as children), it's natural that they become teachers. Another thing that strikes me is how young these women are when they take on their teaching responsibilities. Laura Ingalls is 15 when she gets her teaching certificate. Anne Shirley and Mabel O'Dell are similarly still teenagers, with the equivalent of a high school diploma (Anne later goes to college and earns a bachelor's degree that allows her to become a principal). And while the schools these women work in aren't today's inner city schools, they do have to deal with some pretty difficult things.

That got me to thinking about whether any similar contemporary books are being written for children and young women now. These books are somewhere between young adult literature and chick lit--they were intended as entertainment for adolescent and early/mid teen girls, the characters are flawed but are also supposed to offer something of a role model, and romantic interests come into play once the characters get to be an age where that makes sense (which in most of these stories is about the same time they start teaching). I don't read a lot of contemporary young adult or chick lit, so I don't know if there's anything comparable. The sense I get of chick lit, at least, is that everybody seems to be a publicist or work for a fashion magazine. So where's our modern Anne Shirley or Laura Ingalls? I'm thinking Alice in Eduland would make a great heroine.

No comments: