Rubbing Elbows with the Stars!

This morning I sat in on Business Roundtable's "Fourth Annual NCLB Forum: Assessing Progress, Addressing Problems, Advancing Performance." The panel discussion featured Acting Education Department Under Secretary and Chief of Staff David Dunn, House Education and the Workforce Committee Chair and Ranking member, respectively, Howard "Buck" McKeon and George Miller, and NEA President Reg Weaver, with USA Today's Richard Whitmire moderating.

Considering the venue and mix of speakers, it was probably too much to hope for significant revelations or in-depth discussion, and the panelists performed to expectations. Everyone was utterly predictable and on their best behavior. Rep. McKeon and Mr. Dunn suggested that NCLB is well on its way to solving all our educational woes. Rep. Miller talked seriously about implementation problems and drew a line in the sand regarding under-qualified teachers, saying that the "most important problem is hiring done on the cheap. No longer." But when it came to solutions, he seemed mostly to be saying that if we could just throw a little more money around, we'd be in much better shape. Mr. Weaver also focused on money. He argued that while NCLB's emphasis on outcomes is admirable, it is a distraction from the necessary improvements to incomes in the education system—and then called for the usual litany of smaller classes, multiple measures, growth models, and teacher incentives to move to difficult districts. The panelists seemed to be talking past each other, and no one mentioned the critical educational challenge NCLB aimed to address—racial inequities in education.

Overall, the event just didn't live up to its big-name panel. With actual movers and shakers on the schedule, I was hoping for some moving and shaking. I don't think political posturing and sidestepping count.

--Guestblogger Alex Redfield